Have You Ever Had a Brilliant Idea That Never Saw the Light of Day?
You know that feeling, don't you? You've had what feels like a game-changing idea for your organisation. Something that could genuinely make a difference. But then reality hits - how on earth do you get senior stakeholders on board?
Let's get curious about why so many brilliant ideas remain just that, at best, becoming ideas gathering digital dust deep in someone's folders, rather than transformative initiatives that drive real change.
As well as being wasteful, it is frustrating on a personal level, especially when you see less powerful or impactful ideas being championed.
Why Stakeholder Engagement Matters More Than Your Brilliant Idea
The harsh reality is that the quality of your idea matters far less than your ability to engage the people who can make it happen.
Research by Deloitte shows that companies actively managing and engaging stakeholders are up to 36% more likely to see positive project outcomes.
Yet how many of us actually invest the time upfront to understand what really matters to the decision-makers in our organisations? Unless we really understand what matters to them, how can we know if they will even entertain our idea?
In my experience, most of us rush the initial stages of stakeholder engagement and that not only means that great ideas fall by the wayside, but for those ideas that are taken up, there are consequences right through the project lifecycle and beyond:
- Projects are more likely to fail or be cancelled outright
- Cost overruns become inevitable
- Timelines slip
- Resources get misallocated across the organisation
- Internal credibility takes a significant hit
- Future innovation capacity diminishes as people become reluctant to support new initiatives
Understanding What Senior Stakeholders Actually Care About
So, we know we need to understand our senior stakeholders, but how do we do that. It’s time to get curious about what's really driving them.
McKinsey research consistently identifies several themes that occupy C-suite attention: strategic alignment, financial performance, risk management, stakeholder value, digital transformation, sustainability commitments, and talent management. These are the publicly stated priorities, and our experience tells us two things: firstly, that we need to get really specific about these publicly stated aims and secondly, that their personal motivations and agendas are just as important.
Typically, these hidden motivations will be around three broad areas.
Career protection and advancement. They may be focused on the legacy they want to build and the reputation they want to create and maintain, they may be thinking about avoiding career-damaging failures or the view of their peers and their industry standing may be driving them. They may also be thinking about their next career move and positioning themselves for that.
Control and Influence. Your Stakeholders may be driven by maintaining or extending their control and influence, looking to build their own fiefdom. They may be concerned with maintaining their decision-making authority or span of control, or possibly maintaining their organisational power structure.
Signs of Personal Success. Top of their hidden agenda could be things like performance against their individual targets, the bonus or compensation implications of what you are asking them to consider or the Board or Investors' perceptions of them as an individual.
Knowing which of these board factors are at play for your stakeholders is not, however, enough if you are looking to really understand them, build a trust-led relationship with them and engage them in the ideas you are proposing.
The Applied Curiosity Model
Using the Applied Curiosity Model during and after your conversations with your stakeholders enables you to get to the level of understanding and trust you are looking to build.
You can read more about why building trust is important for PMOs here.
What is the Applied Curiosity Model
Research : Research is the stage where we are gathering data, finding our information, and discovering facts and opinions. We are exploring using skills like listening to understand, asking great questions, reviewing what others have done, reading, listening to podcasts etc.
Reflect: Reflect is where we assimilate and add context to what we have found, turning our data into information we can base our next steps on. Reflection creates the opportunity to add in our reactions, feelings, aspirations, hopes, and what we have learned in the past. It also allows us to explore how the new data links to everything else we know. In the work context, it also allows us to determine the relevance to what we are trying to achieve.
Reflection involves giving yourself time to think and adding some structure to that thinking time. Skills and techniques that can be applied at this stage include discussions, coaching, journaling, thinking walks and other thinking models.
React: This is the ‘so what’ stage of the Applied Curiosity Cycle - where we take what we have found and take action on it. Without this stage, our research and reflection have just been academic and enjoyable, though that is, it is only when we take action that we see the actual benefits for ourselves and our organisations.
We need to form a hypothesis and then experiment with it to see what happens, and this in turn provides new information, which starts the cycle all over again. When it comes to work, we need to build this experiment into our work using our planning processes and skills, as well as the skills we have been using in the research phaseHow can we use the Applied Curiosity Model to help us engage our stakeholders in a new idea?
There are three central questions we need to answer when we start to engage our stakeholders in a new idea
What are their business priorities? These are their publicly stated priorities
What motivates this stakeholder and what matters to them personally? These are their private priorities and agendas
Where does what I want to propose fit with their agendas? What would it matter to them? What is likely to concern them?
Ultimately, we are looking to work out who is most likely to become a key advocate for the idea you want to put forward.
To answer these questions, you can use the Applied Curiosity Model in a number of ways.
Planning your approach
Firstly, the Applied Curiosity Model can provide you with a plan for your approach. The three phases of engaging your senior stakeholders in your idea mimicking the three stages of the Applied Curiosity Cycle.As we look to answer the three central questions, we are going to need to start with a Research Phase.
- Who the key stakeholders are likely to be
- What their public and private agendas are
- What concerns the stakeholders have
The research is likely to be mostly be conversations with the stakeholders themselves, but can also be based on what you already know and the ideas and suggestions of others.
Next will be a Reflect phase, where you pull together everything you have learned from the conversations you have held and your observations with what you already knew. In this phase, you will be reflecting not only on the best positioning for your idea, but also any refinements you need to make to the idea based on the new information you have gathered.
As well as making it easier to talk about our idea in a way that is meaningful and appealing to the stakeholders we are looking to engage in our idea, integrating this new information almost always results in an even more powerful solution.
Finally, we enter the React Phase, where we will decide, based on our reflections, who we are going to engage, when and how we are going to engage them. Your stakeholders are going to need a compelling case for change, evidence-based arguments, to understand the urgency, all presented in tailored communications. The Research and Reflect phases will allow you to do this and develop an impactful, efficient and effective plan of action.But planning is not the only time that using the Applied Curiosity Model will help us engage Stakeholders in the idea we want to propose.
Using the Applied Curiosity Model during your Stakeholder Conversations
The Applied Curiosity Model can also be a great way to structure your conversations with your Stakeholders.
We know we are going into these conversations with some things we are looking to find out, but going in with a curious mind doesn’t necessarily help you know how to manage the conversation and get the outcomes that you want.
Done right, these conversations are a great opportunity to build your relationship with the stakeholder, build trust and demonstrate your value, not through talking about it but by showing the stakeholder your value in action.
I suggest positioning the meeting along the lines of ‘I have had an idea, and before I work on it any further, I want to understand if it is actually going to be of value to use. I appreciate your perspective and would like to ask you some questions.’
Having positioned the meeting, you are going to start with the Research Phase, leading with some great questions that explore the stakeholders' public and private agendas. Great questions are ones where the person being asked is able to answer them in a number of ways, where the answer is not obvious from the question and where the person answering has to think a little. In this case, we will be asking about what matters to them at work at the moment and how that aligns with the corporate agenda and other projects and programmes that are being worked on at the moment.
As you go through the meeting, you will be reflecting to summarise what you have heard and check that your understanding is correct. You will also be discussing with the stakeholder how the various ideas interact and either align or don’t align.Iterating between research and reflection will allow you to dig deeper into your Stakeholders motivations and develop a greater understanding of them as you also build your relationship.
Towards the end of the conversation, you will move into a React Phase where you agree on what the next steps are. They may be obvious with you talking about your idea, or you may need to suggest that you take on board everything they have shared, work on the idea a little more and share it at a later (agreed) date.Using the Applied Curiosity Model after your Stakeholder Conversations
After we have completed our conversations with our stakeholder(s), we need to make sure we are leveraging them. The Research phase of the Applied Curiosity Cycle, after our conversations, focuses on collating everything that we have learned from the conversations and any other sources, such as published strategies and agendas.
The Reflection phase is where the magic happens. This is where we move from data gathering to genuine understanding.
One of Stephen Covey’s 7 Habits of Highly Effective People, which is often forgotten, but is just as true today as when he wrote it in 1989, is "Seek to understand before being understood." People want to know that you genuinely want to hear their perspective first.
During reflection, consider:
- How does your idea align with both the stated organisational priorities AND the personal motivations you've uncovered?
- Does what the stakeholder says match with what you see them doing?
- What language resonates with each stakeholder group?
- Where might competing agendas create challenges?
- What evidence do you have that this idea will deliver measurable outcomes?
Once you have reflected, you will be in a position to form a working hypothesis about how to engage your stakeholders. It is then time to React and plan your next steps
- How will you feedback to the stakeholders?
- How are you going to position your ideas?
- What do you need to do next?
- Who else do you need to talk to?
Conclusions
Using an Applied Curioisty based approach allows us to truly understand our stakeholders’ perspectives and agendas. It also allows us to verify our brilliant idea and make sure it is the right idea for the organisation at the right time.
This approach allows us to refine the ideas so that when we position them to the stakeholders to find our champion and build our stakeholder coalition. Additionally, as we have been doing this, we will have built trust with those stakeholders, which should smooth the path not only of this idea as it becomes a project but also all our other projects, programmes and the entire portfolio.
The questions I would like to leave you with
Now, one of the things I often hear is: "I just don't have time to do all this upfront work."
But two questions I would like to leave you with are:
Do you believe your idea is brilliant enough to be worth investing a little of your time in?
If it is, do you have time not to do the upfront workt?
The time you invest in stakeholder engagement before your idea becomes an active project will save weeks or months of frustration later.
So my final challenge to you is, what if it's actually the difference between your brilliant idea succeeding or joining the graveyard of good intentions?
Curious to know more about engaging your stakeholders?
Book a call and let's chat
Quoted References:
Covey, Stephen. The Seven Habits of Highly Effective People
Deloitte. Stakeholder Capitalism Study. Deloitte Insights.
McKinsey & Company. CEO Excellence Research. McKinsey Global Institute.
Sutterfield, J.S., Friday-Stroud, S.S., and Shivers-Blackwell, S.L. (2006). A Case Study of Project and Stakeholder Management Failures. Project Management Journal, 37(5), 26-35.
